Settlement Agreements: Mediation vs Negotiation in Employment Disputes

Lynn Martelli
Lynn Martelli August 2, 2023
Updated 2023/08/02 at 5:45 AM
Settlement Agreements Mediation vs Negotiation in Employment Disputes

Disputes among employees and employers can arise at any moment, and if you find yourself in such a situation, it is essential to know how to deal with it the right way. Two legal mechanisms commonly used to resolve employment disputes are mediation and negotiation, both of which aim to arrive at an agreement between the parties involved.

Understanding the differences between these two processes is crucial in deciding which method is best for an employment dispute. In this blog post, we will explore the differences between mediation and negotiation, what they involve, and their applicability to employment disputes.


Mediation is a conflict resolution process that involves a neutral third-party mediator helping the parties involved in the settlement agreement. In this process, the mediator does not make rulings; instead, they help the parties communicate, understand each other’s points of view and eventually arrive at a mutually acceptable resolution.

Mediation is generally considered a more informal and flexible process compared to a courtroom trial. The mediator’s goal is to facilitate communication and help parties find common ground, leading to a resolution that is satisfactory to both parties.

Mediation is particularly suitable in employment disputes where the relationship between the employee and employer needs to be maintained. This method helps the parties to preserve a professional working relationship, allowing the employee to return to work without damaging the employer-employee relationship.


Negotiation is a process that involves the employee and employer representatives meeting and discussing the issue to find a mutually acceptable resolution. In this process, both parties present their arguments and supporting documents to the other side in hopes of reaching a compromise that benefits both parties.

Negotiation can be a formal or even informal process, with the parties agreeing to negotiate to resolve the dispute in the early stages of their interactions.

Negotiation is the most commonly used method of resolving employment disputes, as it is a flexible process that allows for a wide range of outcomes. Disputes such as severance pay, allegations of discrimination, or issues with working conditions can all be resolved through negotiation.

Mediation vs negotiation in employment disputes

When dealing with an employment dispute, you may wonder which of these methods is suitable. The answer depends on the specific details of your circumstance. However, here are some points to help you understand when to use mediation or negotiation in an employment dispute.

Mediation is best used when:

– The parties involved wish to maintain a working relationship

– The matter is sensitive or confidential

– To avoid a dispute becoming public

– When parties realize that the legal process is not a feasible option

– And when the parties are interested in being hands-on with the resolution of the dispute

Negotiation is best used when:

– The matter is straightforward, and both parties can adequately articulate their positions

– When parties need to maintain a professional working relationship but are not concerned about confidentiality

– When parties wish to reach a decision quickly

– And when parties desire to have more control over the outcome in the long run


While there is no one-size-fits-all approach to resolving employment disputes, mediation and negotiation are two of the most commonly used methods in the legal system. It is best to speak to an employment law specialist to guide you on the right conflict resolution for your specific case.

Employment disputes may take a toll on you physically and emotionally. However, you can avoid the stress of litigation by seeking amicable resolutions such as mediation and negotiation. Remember, decisions made during these sessions are binding, and this highlights the importance of seeking professional legal guidance when utilizing these methods.

Mediation is often used when parties wish to preserve a relationship, while negotiations are suitable in situations where parties anticipate a long-term collaboration or happy resolution. Knowing when to use mediation and negotiation will guide you in selecting the most suitable conflict resolution mechanism for your specific employment dispute.

Share this Article